![]() |
![]() |
|
|||||||
| Register | Home | Forum | Active Topics | Gallery | Search | Today's Posts | Mark Forums Read |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
|
#181 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 134
Gallery:
0
|
Oh man, good stuff! Running 35's
|
|
|
| Sponsored Links | |
Advertisement |
|
|
|
#182 (permalink) |
|
jimfoo
|
What part do you think I am leaving out? Bill knew I broke lots of axles as I wheel hard for having a Series. Having low power, sometimes you need more momentum to make steep hills or rock sections. If there are bumps, you may loose traction, so the axles will get shock loaded. As you know, that's what breaks them. I'm not positive, but I think it broke going up the right side of Wipeout Hill in Moab, if you know that trail. I didn't quite make the top and it started hopping when I tried to start up from where I stopped on the hill.
__________________
Jim Hall “That man has no respect for his Rover and beats the hell out of it every opportunity he gets, taking the most difficult line over each and every obstacle.” Michael 1966 88" 1.9l VW TDI, GT1749V, IC
|
|
|
|
|
#183 (permalink) | |||||||||||
|
Ian Matthews
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne Australia
Posts: 1,959
Gallery:
0
|
Quote:
To answer your question, both wheels will get power under the circumstances described. Quote:
Quote:
![]() ![]() . I suppose this is based on your real life experience.Quote:
Still avoiding the question. You can offer no explanation as to why it is the side of the DT with the broken axle that breaks and not the side still producing drive. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
![]() ![]() Quote:
When you were including "O" rings as a fault you were also including air lines, compressors, solenoids, etc, etc. So how many "O" rings are there in the complete system? But if we want to now stick to your restricted area of just the locking mechanism inside the diff. Have a look at this and count them. I will even help you..... 1....... 2. I know that this is a bit advanced for your maths level. http://www.arbusa.com/alac/alsp/5-01.pdf Go into your local auto parts store and ask for a rubber "O" ring in the size that you need for your diff lock. Then fit it and see how long it lasts!!! Quote:
You keep on trying to prove your dick is bigger. I already know that mine is and have nothing to prove. Quote:
Quote:
Do you really want to get in that discussion? Haven't you shot yourself enough already? More than happy to discuss. Either reopen the thread you are referring to or start a new one. |
|||||||||||
|
|
|
|
#184 (permalink) | |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 134
Gallery:
0
|
Quote:
I have a feeling, and I have no way to confirm it unless Bill Davis jumps in here, that the "GBR Axles" you had are not the same "HD" axles that we know today. You'd have to be pretty hardcore to snap a 24-spline 4340 Chromo or 300m shaft in a Series truck. And really, I can't see anyone doing it at all with the size tires we traditionally see on Series trucks in the States and the HP involved. |
|
|
|
|
|
#185 (permalink) | |
|
Ian Matthews
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne Australia
Posts: 1,959
Gallery:
0
|
Quote:
"A rangie can pull 4 tonne in standard form. Adding bigger tyres is not going to add any more stress to the drive train than having a huge load hanging off the back of the car." Come on Hank, I am interested in how you will explain how turning over 35's add more stress than pulling 4 tonne. Also remember your previous statements that shock loading does not break axles. ![]() ![]() |
|
|
|
|
|
#186 (permalink) |
|
jimfoo
|
Well if he had 2 different types of steel, I imagine I had the first variety. I was hard on them for 2 years before it broke, including shearing 11 teeth off my ring gear.
__________________
Jim Hall “That man has no respect for his Rover and beats the hell out of it every opportunity he gets, taking the most difficult line over each and every obstacle.” Michael 1966 88" 1.9l VW TDI, GT1749V, IC
|
|
|
|
|
#187 (permalink) |
|
Ian Matthews
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne Australia
Posts: 1,959
Gallery:
0
|
I was going to wait and scan the original documentation that came with my diff lock before finally putting you out of you misery about the oil. But this will have to do. This is a quote from the fitting instructions supplied by ARB on the Zook website:
"12. Refill axle housing with good quality differential oil, referring to vehicle manufacturer's specifications for the oil type and quantity. Although the AIR LOCKER does not require any special gear oil, we recommend using a limited slip differential oil to maximize the life of all differential components." Then this is one from the fitting instructions quoted on the Jeep website: "ARB Air Locker Installation for a model RD30 Air Locker to be installed in a Dana 30 axle Nov 1, 2005 By:ORC STAFF Jeep at Off-Road.com ARB Air Locker Installation 17. Refill the axle housing with good quality differential oil, referring to the manufacturers' specifications for the oil type and quantity. o Although the Air Locker does not require any special gear oil, ARB recommends using a limited slip differential oil to maximize the life of all differential components." Then this is a link to the oil recommended by ARB as regard to Viscosity. You will note that for any real off road work you should use 85/140 http://www.arbusa.com/alac/alsp/6-01.pdf So if you are going to fake emails from ARB, at least do a decent job of it next time!!! |
|
|
|
|
#188 (permalink) | |||||||||||||||||
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 134
Gallery:
0
|
Quote:
Quote:
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Quote:
Quote:
Please, prove me wrong!! Quote:
Quote:
This principle is easy to ilustrate. Take a chain with all but one of the links being 3/8" size. The link in the middle is a 5/16" link. Subject that chain to shock loads. The chain will, of course, break at the 5/16" link all else being equal. This is no surprise. But what is surprising is that chain will also break faster than a chain that has all 5/16" links. Why? Because that single 5/16" takes the hit to the chain while the 3/8" links don't budge. The chain with all 5/16" links distributes the repeated shock loads among all of the links. Take a plastic ruler that is 2" thick and cut down a portion of it to 1" thick. Then twist the ruler. The ruler will snap at the 1" thick section. Then take a plastic ruler that is 1" thick for its entire length. That rule will twist a lot more and take much greater twist load than the first ruler did. These are examples off the top of my head. I know it's hard, but think about it for a while. Many more examples will occur to you. But actually think about something before you say that beefier is better. -JL So, with a waisted design, the engery is stored in the waised part of the shaft. As that axle twists, and ultimatly breaks, all that re-coiled energy produces SHOCK OVERLOAD! Thus, the result is a broken Detroit. Stock axles have a waisted design, which is awesome. This is what allows the axles to twist up to 180+- degrees. What sucks is, the stock axles are made of shit material. Quote:
Quote:
Are Land Rovers the majority of the vehicles that fit a Detroit locker? I'll say it again, MOST VEHICLES that fit a DT do not have a AWD t-case. In MOST VEHICLES, the is power to the pinion when makeing a turn. You're just too stupid to understand the answers that are directly in front of you. Quote:
Oh my God!! My sides are starting to hurt this is so fucking funny! What puts power to the pinion, Ian? Your foot on the brake or your foot on the gas? You got a 50/50 chance here. And here you go about engine brakeing again.... Engine Braking: an engine brake for truck diesel engines that cuts off fuel flow and interrupts the transfer of mechanical energy to the drive mechanism. or the act of using the energy-requiring compression stroke of the internal combustion engine to dissipate energy and slow down a vehicle. So, again, do you back up so fucking fast that you rely on the damn engine to brake you???? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAA! You're clueless, Ian. I don't know what you drive, but my engine powers me backwards - it does not brake me.... Quote:
Quote:
Good boy!!! You finally went and looked it up! You even posted the web site you found it on. You can claim that you knew the answer to this, but we all know you did not. You had to look the answer up before you knew the answer. You tried to say "1" on several occasions.That answer is not correct.That answer is not correct anywhere. Even on your air line, you have 2 O-rings; one at the pump side and 1 at the diff side. You then have 2 inside the diff; the inner and the outter. The one on the inside of the diff are the problem areas. The ones insode the diff are not a "5-minute fix". Quote:
Quote:
Here is a video that shows a race car, in a driving school, diving into a corner. Once in the corner, you can start to drive out. Just as I said...... YouTube - Denny Aungst's in car camera at Dover Nascar School I drive Emergency Vehicles weekly, sometimes daily, Ian. I drive these vehicles at a very high rate of speed with others in the vehicle with me. Both my safety and theirs is at risk. In other words, I know how to fucking drive, Ian. I've never had an accident in these vehicles. And, I'm tested on my skills monthly. I know how to take a corner. Quote:
Quote:
Oh man, Ian. You're so fucking clueless. Please, post something different. That e-mail I posted had nothing to do with "rock crawling" or "off-road". It had everything to do with you not knowing what the fuck you're talking about. Quote:
Yeah, very convient. but yes, I really want to see this. Make sure you include a picture where we can see the color of your blue paint, too. Anything else will be bogus. Quote:
Oh, yes!! I'd really like to discuss it!! Lets talk about how you tried to say you had two lockers!!! Let also point out where you said you've sent you "ARBs" for repair "several times", even though you claim to have never had problem in this thread! Let also talk about where you claimed to have Maxi-Drive axles in that thread, but said HD axles are a waste in this thread. You're an idiot , Ian. ........I'm really like the Spring thread, though. You know, the one where you state that the springs are too stiff to allow front end flex, lol. |
|||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
|
#189 (permalink) | |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Virginia
Posts: 1,592
Gallery:
0
|
Quote:
As I said last night, liar liar pants of fire Ian ![]()
__________________
"From 30,000 feet that swamp looks like a nice green lawn." ![]() =^..^= Hoho Lickin' Kitty Blingin Carpet Muchin Floor Moppin Bubbleheaded Vixen |
|
|
|
|
|
#190 (permalink) | ||
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 134
Gallery:
0
|
Lets see here, In post number 91 you said:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
|
|
|
|
#192 (permalink) | ||||||||||
|
Ian Matthews
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne Australia
Posts: 1,959
Gallery:
0
|
So what you saying is that a locker has benefits other than to stop a wheel from spinning? Come on, stop avoiding the answer. How will a diff lock help when the two wheels involved have perfect traction?
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Your saying it is the shock load that breaks the DT. To have a impact from a shock load, the shock has to be apllied to something. The most likely point for this shock to be applied to is the wheel(axle) that is in contact with the ground (not broken). Therefore you would expect the impact to be felt by the drive flange connected to that axle. But it is the other side of the DT that breaks. So the shock on that side must have had something to impact against. This would indicate that the broken axle was still in one piece and contacting the ground when the DT went bang!!!. Quote:
Quote:
We are not talking about truch engine brakes here. You are just attempting to avoid answering anything. With engine braking (in a 4wd terminology) the power is coming from the wheels through to the motor. That is the reverse direction to what it normally does. When you reverse, the power through the DT is going in the opposite direct to what it normally does. So the forces operating on the DT are the same. Is this sooooo hard for you to understand. So make up your mind! is it locked in reverse, is it locked when power is to the pinion, is it locked when engine braking going down a hill Quote:
Quote:
Now tell us exactly what type of emergency vehicle you drive and where you drive it. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Your pulling out all stops now. You have actually been doing some research. Good on you. Now if you like to read any of my previous posts you will know that I ran standard axles for years with a locker. You will also note that I went to maxidrive axles in the rear only when I went to 4.11 diffs. You should also note that in this thread and others, I have always stated that you need Hd axles in the rear when you go to 4.11's BANG BANG. shot yourself again. So you keep on proving that you know SFA about suspension or diff locks. Last edited by p76rangie : 05-12-2008 at 11:16 PM. |
||||||||||
|
|
|
|
#193 (permalink) | |
|
Ian Matthews
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Melbourne Australia
Posts: 1,959
Gallery:
0
|
Quote:
In regard to the problems with the ARB locker that I had, please post the link to the thread. I can guarantee that it does not list any of the issues that you stated. That is, I have NEVER had any of the problems you stated except I was stupid enough to put a self tapping screw through the air line and not realise it. Hardly a fault with the locker. Last edited by p76rangie : 05-12-2008 at 11:17 PM. |
|
|
|