Disco 2 tire decision - Very confused

[Figman]

Hello there:

I am having a very difficult time deciding on which tires to get; I have a ’01 SE7 with ACE, SLS, 68K miles and worn out GY HPs 18s” that sound like a helicopter.

In the past board members gave good information on my two primary choices: the Nitto Terra Grapplers and the Generals AT2. My mechanic tells me that I am not going to like the AT2 after a couple thousand miles and my tire guy tells me either model I will “feel” more the road because of the tread pattern. Unfortunately I am still undecided on which to go; I have to make a decision this week as my tire guy is waiting for a phone call and the old tires are becoming a safety issue.

Here is why list of features from most important to least important:

1- Safety (make sure the wife and kids are safe while we take family trips)
2- Traction (New York winters require good traction) I don’t do any major off-road but often drive to camping grounds that have gravel and unpaved roads.
3- Looks (I like the look of all terrain tires but don’t know if I will like the everyday driving)
4- Durability (if I get 30K miles I will be happy, the GY HPs have been on for almost 40K miles)
5- Noise ( I don’t really care if the tires produce a bit of noise or less that the worn out GY HP as long as I got get any vibration with the AT tires.

Or should I just get Pirelli Scorpios STR or ATR or something more street like.

I don’t know, I am confused, Help please.

Thanks

Figman

[Disco Mike]

Go to Bridgestone and look at the 3, I believe, different Dueller tires they have, they offer good wear, traction and they are quiet.
Mike

[XtremeMarine]

The bridgestones would be a wise choice, after looking at your criteria. Also the Pirelli Scorpion ATR is another great choice, if it fits in your financial range. I would never recommend the Generals' tires, even to an enemy. And the Nitto's are more than you need.

[Figman]

thanks for your comments; I will check out the Brigdestones

I am still searching ....