I've had these for about 2k miles now and they work great. Not the GREATEST off road tire, actually not in mud atleast, I'm sure they'd do better in dryer terrains, but everywhere else I've taken them, they've performed very well. Tirerack.com members give them HORRIBLE reviews, all coming from Tacoma owners. The tires have very even tread wear and are EXCELLENT road tires. I've noticed some of the Cayenne's with these same tires, right from the dealer. They have really soft rubber which can be good and bad. Overall, I like them, and I think I'll be keeping my Tornado wheels on those and having the MTs with Wolf wheels on them.